Fort Myers/Sanibel Island
What Are You Looking For
Restaurants
Restaurant Rating System
5 Star-A true destination restaurant known for memorable food
4 Star-An excellent food stop of very high quality.
3 Star-Good solid choice for a nice meal.
Steve's Quick Picks
Restaurant
Cape Cod Fish Co
Masala Mantra Indian Bistro
Roadhouse Cafe
Cibo
Fat Katz
Love Boat Ice Cream
Trap House Krab & Seafood
El Gaucho Inca
Coste Island Cuisine
Cielo
Pecking Order Fried Chicken
Joey’s Custard
Paper Fig Kitchen
MAKS Asian Kitchen
Wicked Good Deli
Artisan Eatery
Bruno’s Of Brooklyn
Farmers Market Restaurant
El Patio Peruvian
Rating 1-5
4
4
5
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
5
4
5
5
4
4
4
4
Full Restaurant Details Below
Attractions
Name
Type of Attraction
Rating on 1-5 Scale
Address
Phone Number
Web Site or Facebook
Fort Myers Beach/Fishing Pier
town/fishing pier
4
10 Old San Carlos Blvd Estero Island FL
239/463-3333
Thomas Edison & Henry Ford Winter Estates/Edison Laboratory
historic homes/lab
5
2350 McGregor Blvd
239/334-7419
Lovers Key State Park
state park
5
8700 Estero Blvd Fort Myers Beach Estero Island Fl
239/463-4588
Bailey Matthews National Shell Museum
museum
5
3075 Sanibel Captiva Rd Sanibel FL
239/395-2233
J.N. Darling National Wildlife Refuge
wildlife refuge
5
1 Wildlife Dr Sanibel FL
239/472-1100
Sanibel Moorings Botanical Garden
botanical garden
4
845 E Gulf Dr Sanibel FL
239/472-4119
Sanibel & Captiva Islands Visitors Information Center
visitor center
4
1159 Causeway Rd Sanibel FL
239/472-1080
Clinic for Rehabilitation of Wildlife (CROW)
wildlife rehab
4
3883 Sanibel Captiva Rd Sanibel FL
239/472-3644
Sanibel & Captiva Conservation Foundation Nature Center
nature center
4
3333 Sanibel Captiva Rd Sanibel FL
239/472-2329
All Area Restaurants With Details
Restaurant
Rating On 1-5 Scale
Price Category
Type Of Cuisine
Address
Phone
Menu Favorite
Location Within State
Website
Masala Matra Indian Bistro
5
moderate
indian
4518 Del Prado Blvd South Cape Coral FL
239/540-6300
chicken tikka masala
butter chicken
gobi manchurian
bombay lamb chops
vindaloo
korma
mixed grill
samosa chaat
saag paneer
biriyani
southwest coast
Love Boat Ice Cream
5
inexpensive
ice cream
16475 San Carlos Blvd
239/466-7707
coconut almond fudge
chocolate chunk in chocolate dipped waffle cone
clean turtle
oatmeal cream pie
creamsicle
watermelon sorbet
southwest coast
Trap House Krab & Seafood
5
moderate
seafood
2150 Fowler St Ste 110
239/203-5364
blue or snow crab clusters
perfect storm combo
mac daddy
six fifty
fried 239 combo
southwest coast
El Gaucho Inca
4
moderate
peruvian
4383 Colonial Blvd Ste 100
239/275-7504
lomo saltado
skirt steak
pescado ala macho
ceviche mixto
ribeye
parmesan scallops
tacu tacu
whitefish
southwest coast
Cibo
4
expensive
italian
12901 McGregor Blvd Ste 16
239/454-3700
ricotta gnocchi
spaghetti bolognese
lobster ravioli
bread
eggplant parmesan
penne vodka
cannoli
tiramisu
grouper
scallop saltimbocca
southwest coast
Roadhouse Cafe
4
expensive
steakhouse
15660 San Carlos Blvd Ste 280
239/415-4375
sweet italian sausage penne pasta
lobster bisque
seafood casserole
stuffed pork chop
seafood fra diablo
crab cakes
rack of lamb
spinach salad
southwest coast
Cape Cod Fish Co
4
moderate
seafood
15501 Old McGregor Blvd
239/313-6462
lobster roll
fried clams
clam chowder
cod fish n chips
lobster corn chowder
calamari
fried shrimp po boy
clam cakes
shrimp plate
blackened salmon
captains basket
southwest coast
Coste Island Cuisine
5
expensive
seafood/steakhouse
2000 Estero Bld Fort Myers Beach Estero Island Fl (in Diamondhead Beach Resort)
877/548-1528
lobster carbonara
crab cakes
short ribs
NY strip
short rib slider
steak au poivre
pork belly poutine
pork chop
island chowder
southwest coast
Joey’s Custard
5
inexpensive
custard
2467 Periwinkle Way Sanibel FL
239/472-7222
kings crown
exhausted parents
me want cookie
chocolate vanilla soft serve
expresso chip
shakes
key lime pie
bourbon pecan
southwest coast
Paper Fig Kitchen
5
moderate
american
2003 Periwinkle Way Sanibel FL
239/887-0050
brit brit club
avocado toast
mermaid sandwich
shrimp & chorizo tacos
watermelon feta cucumber salad
lemonade
quiche
chocolate croissant
coffee cake
southwest coast
Cielo
4
expensive
american
1244 Periwinkle Way Sanibel FL
239/472-5555
mussels cielo
chicken pot pie
sea bass
halibut
wagyu meatballs
rack of lamb
calamari
pork shank
southwest coast
Pecking Order Fried Chicken
4
inexpensive
american
2496 Palm Ridge Rd Sanibel FL
239/472-2534
chicken pot pie
white meat combo
chicken breasts
biscuits w/spicy maple sauce
mac n cheese
strawberry rhubarb pie
chicken soup
mashed potatoes & gravy
southwest coast
Clam Shack
4
moderate
seafood
2407 Periwinkle Way Sanibel FL
239/472-6882
lobster roll
clam chowder
cod fish n chips
lobster bisque
clam strips
fried shrimp
fish sandwich
ipswich clams
clam bake
lobster salad
southwest coast
MAKS Asian Kitchen
4
moderate
asian/sushi
13650 Fiddlesticks Blvd Ste 206
239/985-9632
mongolian beef bento box
teriyaki chicken bento box
hot & sour soup
spicy tuna roll
red chicken curry
salmon or tuna crispy rice
pad thai
devil or green monster roll
southwest coast
Sanibel Fish House
4
moderate
seafood
1523 Periwinkle Way Sanibel Island FL
239/472-7770
snow crab legs
coconut shrimp
fish tacos
conch fritters
shrimp corn chowder
lobster mac
stuffed grouper
southwest coast
Wicked Good Deli
4
inexpensive
deli
3940 Metro Pkwy
239/887-4652
turkey club
NY pastrami
fries
cheesesteak
chicken parmesan
tuna wrap
famous steak bomb
meatball
southwest coast
Osteria Celli
4
moderate
italian
15880 Summerlin Rd
239/267-1310
fettucine bolognese
cioppino
pacccheri pasta
lumaache
gnocchi lombardi
pappardelle alla sarda
polpo
orecchiette
burrata
calamari
branzino
tiramisu
bruschetta
carpaccio
southwest coast
Mason’s Famous Lobster Roll
4
moderate
seafood
2122 1st St
239/208-7271
classic lobster roll
connecticut roll
lobster BLT roll
lobster salad roll
lobster mac n cheese
bar harbor roll
southwest coast
Salty Papa’s Shrimp House
4
moderate
seafood
15271 McGregor Blvd Ste 1
239/482-7272
charleston shrimp & grits
gumbo
fried shrimp
shrimp or oyster po boy
boiled shrimp
bacon wrapped shrimp skewers
crab & corn chowder
coconut shrimp
fried chicken
southwest coast
Artisan Eatery
4
moderate
american
8951 Daniels Pkwy
239/887-4844
shrimp & grits
lobster roll
truffled eggs benedict
artisan or impossible burger
parmesan truffle fries
port richmond cheesesteak
french toast
breakfast burrito
blackened mahi sandwich or taco
mediterranean wrap
wings
sweet potato fries
southwest coast
Bruno’s of Brooklyn
4
moderate
italian
2112 2nd St
239/278-0211
lasagna
chicken or veal parmesan
four cheese ravioli w/meatballs
fiocchi alla bianco
meatball appetizer
pistachio gelato
arancini
calamari
penne vodka
veal piccata
rigatoni bolognese
caprese salad
berries & cream
broccoli rabe
southwest coast
Farmers Market Restaurant
4
moderate
southern
2736 Edison Ave
239/334-1687
fried chicken
country fried steak
fried pork chops
large chicken wings
pulled pork sandwich
corn fritters
coconut cream pie
biscuits & gravy
sweet potato pie
fried ribs
collard greens
smothered chicken
liver & onions
fried zucchini
chicken tenders
southwest coast
El Patio Peruvian
4
moderate
peruvian
4444 Cleveland Ave Ste E
239/278-3303
grilled red snapper
tacu tacu con lomo saltado
baby beef steak
ceviche mixto
ceviche de pescado cameron
steak parilla
aji de gallina
pescado ala macho
southwest coast
Buckingham Farms Restaurant
4
moderate
american
12931 Orange River Blvd
239/206-2303
crab cake BLT
barnyard chicken sandwich
tropical fried pan fish
crab cake salad
quesadilla
reuben
cuban sandwich
corned beef sandwich
peanut butter pie
pulled pork
chicken salad
southwest coast
Downtown House of Pizza
4
moderate
pizza
1520 Hendry St
239/337-3467
sicilian white pizza
pepperoni
cheese
meat lovers
cannoli
tomato basil w/chicken
supreme
garlic knots
big meat lovers stromboli
southwest coast